A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song

A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song aims to modernize the classic fairy tale but often stumbles under the weight of its own clichés. With a runtime of just 88 minutes, it feels both rushed and padded at the same time.

Cinderella with a Modern Twist

The film follows Katie Gibbs, played by Lucy Hale, a talented aspiring singer at a performing arts high school. She falls for the charming new student, Luke (Freddie Stroma), as she struggles against the oppressive schemes of her stepmother and stepsister, who seem determined to thwart her dreams. As the plot unfolds, Katie's journey to self-discovery and romance takes center stage, but the predictability often gets in the way of genuine excitement. Ultimately, viewers are treated to a generic take on the Cinderella story that leaves little impact.

Performances in a Familiar Frame

Lucy Hale gives a spirited performance as Katie, attempting to embody the enthusiasm and naiveté of her character. Freddie Stroma as Luke provides a charming counterpart, though his character is disappointingly underdeveloped, leaving audiences wanting more from their interactions. Missi Pyle's portrayal of the wicked stepmother feels one-dimensional, lacking depth that could have made her character more interesting. The supporting cast, including Alyson Stoner, adds some fun but mostly fills cliched roles that don’t contribute much to the overall narrative.

A Visual Approach That Falls Flat

Damon Santostefano’s direction keeps things light, but the visual style feels strangely uninspired for a film set in a performing arts environment. The cinematography lacks flair, relying heavily on typical high school tropes rather than showcasing the vibrant potential of its setting. The pacing is erratic; some scenes drag while others rush through potentially meaningful moments. Overall, while the film tries to establish a whimsical tone, it often lands flat due to missed opportunities in its visual storytelling.

Casual Watching, Minimal Impact

Watching A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song is akin to flipping through a familiar fairytale—comforting, yet ultimately bland. The film captures some sweet moments, especially during the musical sequences, but it frequently falls into dull territory with predictable plot twists. The emotional stakes are low, leading to moments of boredom rather than tension or excitement. You might find yourself checking the time as the film moves through its formulaic paces, longing for a spark that never fully ignites.