What If

What If is a light romantic comedy that explores the complexities of friendship and love. While it offers some charming moments, it doesn't fully capitalize on its premise.

A Complicated Friendship

The film centers around Wallace, a medical-school dropout portrayed by Daniel Radcliffe, who, after a series of disappointing relationships, decides to take a break from dating. His life changes when he meets Chantry, played by Zoe Kazan, an animator who is already in a long-term relationship with Ben. Their chemistry is undeniable, leading them to question if their deep friendship could evolve into something more. As they navigate their feelings, the film examines the often blurry lines between friendship and romantic connection, set against the backdrop of Toronto.

Radcliffe and Kazan Shine

Daniel Radcliffe brings a relatable awkwardness to Wallace, effectively capturing his struggles with romance. Zoe Kazan complements him well as Chantry, embodying a warm yet conflicted character. Adam Driver, as Wallace's friend Allan, provides some humorous moments, though his character feels somewhat underdeveloped. The chemistry between Radcliffe and Kazan is palpable, making their connection the film's highlight, while some secondary characters, like Ben and Dalia, don't get the depth they deserve.

Bright Yet Simple Visuals

Michael Dowse’s direction strikes a balance between comedy and drama, although it occasionally falters when trying to blend the two. The visuals are bright and engaging, showcasing Toronto nicely, but they don't push any boundaries. The editing is straightforward, keeping the pace consistent, though some scenes could have benefited from a tighter cut. The animation sequences depicting Chantry’s work add a unique flair, providing a visual break from the typical rom-com format.

Cozy but Surface-Level

Watching What If, there's a light-heartedness that lingers, but it doesn't shy away from the complexities of love and friendship. The film feels cozy and relatable, especially for anyone who's been caught in the 'friend-zone' dilemma. While it has its comedic moments, there are also quiet, introspective scenes that invite reflection on personal relationships. However, the emotional depth may not resonate with everyone, potentially feeling a bit superficial at times.